November 19, 2026
Most of this fall's Forsyth County market shows up in two houses on Hillshire Drive in Cumming. Peachtree Residential has cut the price of 3350 Hillshire Drive by a total of $162,579 since it first went on sale. Down the street at 3310 Hillshire Drive, the total cut is $164,900. Both homes had been for sale for more than a year when North Atlanta Star reported the numbers on October 7. "They didn't all happen at once. It has been a trickle effect," Carol Morgan told the paper. She was answering questions on behalf of the builder.
Compare that with the county's resale numbers. North Atlanta Star reported that Forsyth had 175 residential sales through Georgia MLS in October 2026, down from 232 in October 2025. The median sale price didn't change at all. It was $585,000 both years. So sales fell by about a quarter and prices stayed put. Right now, the sellers making six-figure cuts are the ones with a closing deadline to meet.
The FMLS figures for September 2026 show how slowly resale is moving. The county had 1,386 homes for sale at the end of the month, 11.2% more than a year earlier. Accepted contracts fell 25.1%, to 185. Months of supply rose to 5.2. The average home sold that month took 81 days, counting its full listing history, and went for 93.9% of its original asking price.
October's FMLS figures were almost the same: 5.4 months of supply, 78 days on market, and 94.7% of the original asking price, with a median sale price of $625,000. In plain terms, a resale seller in Forsyth this fall typically gave up about five or six percent of their first asking price and waited close to three months to do it. On a home first listed at $600,000, a 94.7% result means about $31,800 below the original price. Buyers can get that, but they get it slowly. It's also small next to what some builders have taken off.
In the same North Atlanta Star roundup, a local agent described the gap in Cumming, Suwanee and Johns Creek: sellers expect more than buyers are willing to pay. Buyers are still out there, he said, but they're pickier. He added that prices holding steady doesn't necessarily mean homes are selling easily.
Builders' promotions are tied to a closing date, and both of the big Cumming offers this season expire within weeks of Thanksgiving.
Peachtree Residential started its Fall Home Finale on October 1. It takes up to $100,000 off select move-in-ready homes, and buyers have to close by December 31, 2026, according to Atlanta Real Estate Forum. The announcement named four Forsyth communities. Arden on Lanier, Hillshire and The Glade are in Cumming, and White Post on Lake Lanier is in east Forsyth. It also listed specific homes with their prices on October 1. 4405 Ryker Road at Arden on Lanier was $689,500. 3380 Hillshire Drive, a one-level home with a finished terrace level, was $698,500. 2390 Glade Overlook, on a 1.29-acre lot, was $1,399,900. In early November, the builder listed eight available homes at Hillshire, priced from $599,900 to $725,000.
Toll Brothers is running its own year-end offer on quick move-in homes in Cumming. Its schedule runs one week longer than Peachtree's. The offer covers buyers who sign a contract on or after October 8, 2026 and close by January 8, 2027. At The Crossing at Coal Mountain, Toll lists townhomes from $474,995 in the Cottonwood collection and $504,995 in Haven. Single-family homes start at $579,995 in Heartland and $679,995 in Magnolia. The page shows 20 quick move-in homes in the community.
As of the week before Thanksgiving, that leaves about six weeks before Peachtree's December 31 deadline and about seven before Toll's January 8 deadline. Both are closing dates, not contract dates, and the holiday weeks fall inside them.
These two builders aren't discounting the same way. On Peachtree's behalf, Morgan put it plainly in the North Atlanta Star report: "Instead of offering discounted financing through a buydown, Peachtree Residential is reducing home prices."
Toll Brothers lowers the rate instead. Its Cumming promotion is a 5.49% 30-year fixed rate, 5.76% APR, on select quick move-in homes, with as little as 10% down. The loan has to go through Toll Brothers Mortgage Company. Toll's printed example uses a $555,556 sale price, a $500,000 loan and a 740 credit score, with a payment of $5.67 per $1,000 borrowed. That works out to $2,835 a month in principal and interest on the $500,000 loan. Toll can change or withdraw the offer at any time, and it can't be combined with other offers.
The two kinds of discount help different buyers. A price cut stays with the house no matter who your lender is or how much you put down. A rate offer is worth the most to someone borrowing a lot and planning to use the builder's own mortgage company. North Atlanta Star gave the same advice about Hillshire. A buyer should judge a home by its current price against similar homes for sale, not by the size of the advertised savings.
| Builder and community | Listed price | Year-end offer as listed | Must close by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peachtree Residential, Hillshire | $599,900 to $725,000, early November | Up to $100,000 off select move-in-ready homes | December 31, 2026 |
| Peachtree Residential, Arden on Lanier and The Glade | High $600,000s to the $1.3 millions, October 1 | Up to $100,000 off select move-in-ready homes | December 31, 2026 |
| Toll Brothers, The Crossing at Coal Mountain | Townhomes from $474,995, single-family from $579,995 | 5.49% fixed rate on select quick move-in homes | January 8, 2027 |
| Ashton Woods, Sterling Crest | $704,900 to $989,900 | Up to $50,000 in design selections for the first five home sales | No closing date on the offer |
Rates, prices and promotions here are what the builders listed on the dates shown. This is general information, not financial or legal advice, so confirm the terms for your own purchase with your lender and the right professional before you rely on any of it.
The Ashton Woods row in that table is a different kind of offer. Sterling Crest has just started selling, and its design credit goes to the first five buyers. That's a launch incentive meant to get early sales going. The Hillshire cuts are the opposite: homes that are already built and need to be sold. The discounts on finished homes this season come from a building pipeline that started years ago, and the county has been narrowing that pipeline.
The Forsyth County Board of Commissioners voted on October 15 and again on November 5, 2026 to extend two residential development moratoriums into spring 2027, according to the county's land development page.
New projects are still coming, just in small numbers. Appen Media reported that commissioners approved a Toll Brothers subdivision on June 5: 224 acres and 242 lots at Westminster Lane and Old Atlanta Road in south Forsyth. David Weekley Homes announced Heritage Oaks on October 27. It's a 46-home gated community in Cumming on 100-foot lots, with a launch projected for winter 2026, per Atlanta Real Estate Forum. Projects like these tend to start with launch incentives like Sterling Crest's, not clearance prices like Hillshire's. Builders discount most once a home is finished and sitting, which is where the move-in-ready homes are right now.
Are these builder offers guaranteed through their deadlines? No. Toll Brothers says it can change or withdraw its rate offer at any time and that the rate may run out without notice. Peachtree Residential's promotion applies only to select homes and can also change or be withdrawn without notice. Prices listed in October or early November may have changed since.
Does a flat county median mean Forsyth resale homes aren't negotiable? No. Resale sellers in Forsyth got 94.7% of their original asking price on average in October 2026, according to FMLS data, after a 78-day average time on the market. Resale sellers do come down. The October average was a bit over five percent below the original asking price. Two Hillshire homes have been cut by more than $160,000 each over more than a year on the market, and their builder is working against a December 31 closing date.
Can I combine a builder's rate offer with a price reduction? Toll Brothers says its 5.49% offer can't be combined with any other offer. Peachtree Residential discounts through lower prices instead of rate buydowns.
If you're comparing a builder's finished home in Cumming with resale homes nearby, SET Real Estate Group can compare them side by side for you: the current price, the price history, the closing deadline and what the incentive is actually worth. That's easiest to do with time left before the December 31 and January 8 deadlines.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
A Simple Guide to Georgia Real Estate Terms for Brookhaven, GA Buyers and Sellers.
Room-by-Room Staging Strategies That Help Brookhaven, GA Homes Stand Out.
From Lakeside Loops to Greenway Rides, Here Are the Outdoor Activities in Brookhaven, GA Worth Planning Around.
Location, Property Condition, and Holding Costs All Shape ROI for Brookhaven GA Real Estate.
At SET Real Estate Group, they are passionate about helping clients fulfill their real estate goals. As a team, they don't look at every sale or purchase as just another transaction, but as opportunities to cultivate lasting and meaningful relationships with each of their clients.